Skip to content
ALL METAL BRAKE

Outage Heaters comparison

Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater vs Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater

Updated November 17, 2026 ยท Based on manufacturer spec sheets and our AMB Score. We may earn a commission from links.

Quick answer

The Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater scores higher (93 vs 91/100). Pick the Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater if you want larger Rooms; pick the Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater for overall Indoor Heater.

Specs Side by Side

SpecMr. Heater Big Buddy Propane HeaterMr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater
AMB Score91/10093/100
Price bandSee current priceSee current price
Heat output4,000/9,000/18,000 BTU4,000/9,000 BTU
FeaturesIndoor-Safe, Two CylindersIndoor-Safe, ODS + Tip-Over

Highlighted rows are where the two differ.

Where They Differ

  • Heat output: the Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater has 4,000/9,000/18,000 BTU; the Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater has 4,000/9,000 BTU.
  • Features: the Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater has Indoor-Safe, Two Cylinders; the Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater has Indoor-Safe, ODS + Tip-Over.

How They Score

Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater: 91/100

Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater: 93/100

Buy the Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater Ifโ€ฆ

You want larger Rooms. Choose it when the warm room is a living room rather than a bedroom, or when the whole household is bunking together in one space.

Skip it if the high setting burns fuel quickly and calls for more ventilation.

Pros

  • Three settings reaching 18,000 BTU, enough for a living room or open family area
  • Indoor-safe rating, with an oxygen depletion sensor and a tip-over shutoff
  • Carries two 1-lb cylinders, about doubling the time between swaps
  • An optional battery-powered fan spreads warmth across a larger room

Cons

  • The high setting burns fuel quickly and calls for more ventilation
  • Larger and heavier than the Portable Buddy
  • More heater than a single bedroom needs

Buy the Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater Ifโ€ฆ

You want overall Indoor Heater. The go-to indoor emergency heater for most households: it warms one closed-off room, it is easy to run, and it carries the safety devices that matter.

Skip it if on high, a 1-lb cylinder lasts only a few hours, so keep a deep supply.

Pros

  • Mr. Heater sells it as indoor-safe, fitted with an oxygen depletion sensor and a tip-over shutoff
  • Two heat settings: low to carry you through the night, high to warm up a cold room
  • Rated for roughly 225 square feet, about the size of a typical bedroom
  • Burns a 1-lb propane cylinder and needs no electricity whatsoever
  • Piezo ignition and a fold-down handle make it simple to light and set in place

Cons

  • On high, a 1-lb cylinder lasts only a few hours, so keep a deep supply
  • The manual requires a fresh-air opening, which lets some heat escape
  • The front grille runs hot enough to burn skin and scorch fabric

FAQ

Which is better, the Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater or the Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater?

The Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater scores higher (93 vs 91/100). Pick the Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater if you want larger Rooms; pick the Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater for overall Indoor Heater.

What is the main difference between the Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater and Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater?

Heat output: Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater 4,000/9,000/18,000 BTU vs Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater 4,000/9,000 BTU. Features: Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater Indoor-Safe, Two Cylinders vs Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater Indoor-Safe, ODS + Tip-Over.

Which is cheaper, the Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater or the Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater?

Prices on both move often with sales and stock, so we do not quote them. Check both current prices before you buy, and compare on running watts, capacity and features first.

Who should skip the Mr. Heater Big Buddy Propane Heater?

Skip it if the high setting burns fuel quickly and calls for more ventilation. Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Propane Heater: skip it if on high, a 1-lb cylinder lasts only a few hours, so keep a deep supply.