Skip to content
ALL METAL BRAKE

Whole-House Surge Protectors comparison

Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device vs Square D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80

Updated November 17, 2026 ยท Based on manufacturer spec sheets and our AMB Score. We may earn a commission from links.

Quick answer

The Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device scores higher (93 vs 87/100). Pick the Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device if you want most buyers; pick the Square D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80 for smallest Footprint.

Specs Side by Side

SpecSiemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge DeviceSquare D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80
AMB Score93/10087/100
Price bandSee current priceSee current price
FeaturesType 1 or 2, 140 kA, Outdoor-Rated EnclosureCompact 80 kA Unit, Knockout or Surface Install

Highlighted rows are where the two differ.

Where They Differ

  • Features: the Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device has Type 1 or 2, 140 kA, Outdoor-Rated Enclosure; the Square D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80 has Compact 80 kA Unit, Knockout or Surface Install.

How They Score

Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device: 93/100

Square D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80: 87/100

Buy the Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device Ifโ€ฆ

You want most buyers. The best all-round choice for most homes, with the headroom to last through years of surges.

Skip it if larger housing than compact devices.

Pros

  • 140 kA surge current rating per Siemens
  • Listed for Type 1 or Type 2 installation
  • Enclosure suits indoor or outdoor mounting
  • Status LEDs show protection state
  • Works with any brand of panel when wired to a breaker

Cons

  • Larger housing than compact devices
  • Costs more than basic units

Buy the Square D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80 Ifโ€ฆ

You want smallest Footprint. A compact, well-known device that suits most panels at a reasonable price.

Skip it if lower capacity than premium options.

Pros

  • 80 kA surge rating per Square D
  • Compact housing fits tight spaces
  • Mounts through a knockout or on a surface
  • LED status indicators
  • Works with any panel when wired to a breaker

Cons

  • Lower capacity than premium options
  • Indicator LEDs are small

FAQ

Which is better, the Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device or the Square D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80?

The Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device scores higher (93 vs 87/100). Pick the Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device if you want most buyers; pick the Square D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80 for smallest Footprint.

What is the main difference between the Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device and Square D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80?

Features: Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device Type 1 or 2, 140 kA, Outdoor-Rated Enclosure vs Square D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80 Compact 80 kA Unit, Knockout or Surface Install.

Which is cheaper, the Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device or the Square D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80?

Prices on both move often with sales and stock, so we do not quote them. Check both current prices before you buy, and compare on running watts, capacity and features first.

Who should skip the Siemens FirstSurge Pro FS140 Surge Device?

Skip it if larger housing than compact devices. Square D Home Electronics Protective Device HEPD80: skip it if lower capacity than premium options.